8 questions

Michigan Contracting Law & Unlicensed Practice

An unlicensed Michigan builder completes residential work and then sues the homeowner for the unpaid balance. Under MCL 339.2412, what is the result?

  • a.The builder may collect the full contract price as long as the work passed final inspection
  • b.The builder may not bring or maintain a court action to collect compensation for the work✓
  • c.The homeowner must pay double damages because the work was completed and accepted
  • d.The builder may sue for the cost of materials but not for the labor on the job

Under MCL 339.2412, a builder who was unlicensed when the work was performed may not bring or maintain an action in any Michigan court to collect compensation for that work — losing the right to sue for either the contract price or the value of labor and materials.MCL 339.2412

Michigan Contracting Law & Unlicensed Practice

Under the Michigan Construction Lien Act, within what time after last furnishing labor or materials must a claimant record a Claim of Lien?

  • a.Within one year
  • b.Within 10 days
  • c.Within 90 days✓
  • d.Within 30 days

The Michigan Construction Lien Act (MCL 570.1101 et seq.) requires a Claim of Lien to be recorded within 90 days after the claimant last furnished labor or materials to the project.Michigan Construction Lien Act, MCL 570.1111

Michigan Contracting Law & Unlicensed Practice

After recording a Claim of Lien in Michigan, within what time must the claimant start a proceeding to enforce (foreclose) the lien?

  • a.There is no deadline once the lien is recorded
  • b.Within 90 days of recording
  • c.Within 30 days of recording
  • d.Within one year of recording the Claim of Lien✓

Under the Construction Lien Act, a claimant must commence a proceeding to enforce the lien within one year after the Claim of Lien is recorded, or the lien is lost.Michigan Construction Lien Act, MCL 570.1117

Michigan Contracting Law & Unlicensed Practice

A Michigan subcontractor not in direct contract with the owner wants to preserve construction-lien rights. What step is generally required soon after starting work?

  • a.Nothing, because lien rights attach automatically and no notice is needed from a subcontractor
  • b.Filing a lawsuit against the owner within 10 days of first furnishing labor or materials
  • c.Recording a Claim of Lien with the register of deeds before any labor or materials are furnished
  • d.Serving a Notice of Furnishing, generally within 20 days of first furnishing labor or materials✓

Under the Construction Lien Act, a claimant not contracting directly with the owner generally must serve a Notice of Furnishing within 20 days of first furnishing labor or materials to preserve lien rights.Michigan Construction Lien Act, MCL 570.1109 (Notice of Furnishing)

Michigan Contracting Law & Unlicensed Practice

Which of the following is a ground for disciplining a Michigan residential builder under MCL 339.2411?

  • a.Diverting project funds or failing to account for money received✓
  • b.Hiring licensed subcontractors to perform part of a project
  • c.Carrying more liability insurance than a contract calls for
  • d.Charging market-rate prices for residential building work

MCL 339.2411 lists the conduct that subjects a builder to discipline. It includes abandoning a contract without legal excuse, diverting funds or property received for a project, failing to account for money that belongs to others, and willfully departing from plans or specifications without the owner's consent. Fraud is a ground under the code's general provisions (MCL 339.604).MCL 339.2411 (grounds for discipline)

Michigan Contracting Law & Unlicensed Practice

Under Michigan's builder rules, what must a licensed residential builder's advertising show?

  • a.The licensee's name and a telephone number, with nothing else
  • b.The licensee's name and a post office box, with nothing else
  • c.The licensee's name, license number, and business address✓
  • d.The license number and the year the license was first issued

Rule R 338.1532 requires advertising to show the licensee's name, license number, and actual business address. A telephone number or post office box alone is not enough. Separately, MCL 339.2404a requires a licensee to give license information as part of the contract.Mich Admin Code R 338.1532; MCL 339.2404a

Michigan Contracting Law & Unlicensed Practice

Why is holding a valid Michigan license so important to a builder's ability to get paid?

  • a.It has no effect on collection rights, because any builder can sue on a signed written contract
  • b.Because an unlicensed builder cannot sue to collect, licensure is a precondition to using the courts to enforce payment✓
  • c.It matters only because it lowers the permit fees that local building departments charge a builder
  • d.It lets the builder charge double the contract price whenever a homeowner pays an invoice late

Because MCL 339.2412 bars an unlicensed builder from suing to collect, a builder must be licensed at the time of the work to preserve the right to enforce payment through the courts.MCL 339.2412 (effect of licensure on collection)

Michigan Contracting Law & Unlicensed Practice

In Michigan, acting as a residential builder without the required license, in addition to barring a suit to collect, may also result in:

  • a.Automatic issuance of a license
  • b.A tax refund to the builder
  • c.Criminal penalties for unlicensed practice✓
  • d.A warning with no other consequence in any case

Unlicensed residential contracting in Michigan is not only a bar to collecting through the courts. Under MCL 339.601 it is also a crime: a first offense is a misdemeanor with a fine of $5,000 to $25,000, up to one year in jail, or both.MCL 339.601 (unlicensed practice)