Penal Code §240 defines assault as an unlawful attempt, coupled with present ability, to commit a violent injury on another person. For a guard, which scenario most clearly meets all assault elements?
Explanation
Assault under PC §240 requires (1) an unlawful attempt (2) coupled with present ability (3) to commit a violent injury. Raising a baton overhead within striking range of a compliant person creates immediate present ability to inflict violent injury and, absent privilege, is an unlawful attempt. The suspect's compliance removes any self-defense or force-incident-to-arrest privilege. Verbal warnings of lawful arrest (b), ready-position carry during peaceful escort (c), and gestures directing egress (d) do not meet the 'present ability to commit violent injury' threshold. Assault liability for guards arises most often from drawn or raised weapons against non-resistant persons.
Law Reference: Cal. Penal Code §240Practice all 200 questions free — no signup required.
Related questions on this topic
- Penal Code §236 defines false imprisonment as 'the unlawful violation of the personal liberty of another.' Which of the following is the most accurate civil-liability description for a security guard?
- Under Penal Code §237, false imprisonment is punishable as a felony when it is effected by:
- Penal Code §242 defines battery as any willful and unlawful use of force or violence upon the person of another. Which of the following best describes the standard for security guards?
- A security guard observes a person who has been previously warned, in writing, not to return to a posted business property. The person re-enters the premises. Under PC §602(o) and related subdivisions, the guard's legal posture is:
- Under respondeat superior and BPC §7583.39, a licensed PPO (private patrol operator) is generally liable for its employee guard's torts committed:
- A PPO hires a guard without conducting the BSIS-mandated background check. The guard later commits an assault against a patron. Beyond respondeat superior, the PPO may face liability under which independent theory?
Last reviewed: · editorial process