An owner and contractor dispute whether a certain task was included in the fixed price. The contract's clear, integrated scope of work does not list that task. Under general interpretation principles, the task is most likely:
Explanation
A clear, integrated scope of work sets the boundary of the fixed price; a task outside it is an extra, and it becomes compensable when the owner orders it. On home improvement work that order must be a change order in writing, signed before the changed work begins (B&P §7159(d)), and §7159(e)(3) requires the contract to warn the buyer that extras without such an order are unenforceable against him. (a) is the owner's version of the argument, and it proves too much: if a fixed price covered anything anyone later wanted, the scope clause would mean nothing. (b) misapplies the Statute of Frauds, which decides which agreements need a writing at all (Civil Code §1624), not whether an integrated contract can be added to. (d) blames the contractor for not pricing work nobody asked him to price.
Law Reference: Bus. & Prof. Code §7159(d), §7159(e)(3); cf. Civil Code §1624This topic, taught in full in the CSLB Law & Business guide. CSLB Law & Business — Complete Study Guide (2026) — PDF + EPUB, $24.99 · 14-day refund →
Practice all 1632 questions free — no signup required.
Own the complete CSLB Law & Business guide — PDF + EPUB, $24.99 →
Related questions on this topic
- An 'attorney fees' clause in a contract typically provides that:
- A contractor and owner sign a contract, then later sign a separate written agreement that clearly changes the completion date and adds $6,000 in scope. This later signed agreement is best described as:
- In a T&M contract dispute, the single most important documentation supporting the contractor's invoices is usually:
- A key reason a contractor should ensure the person signing a contract has authority to bind the property is that:
- Overall, the single most effective way for a contractor to prevent and win contract disputes over scope, extras, and payment is to:
- A remodeler's printed contract for a single-family home carries an arbitration provision in the same 9-point type as the rest of the document, under the heading 'Dispute Resolution', with no separate space for the owner to initial. What does Bus. & Prof. Code §7191 make of it?
Last reviewed: · editorial process